Straight Wharf Fish Menu

Straight Wharf Fish in Nantucket offers a memorable seafood experience right on the harbor. This fresh, local-centric menu shines with raw and fried oysters, perfectly shucked and priced at just $4 each, delivering the briny taste of the sea in every bite. Their iconic lobster roll, available warm or cold, is a rich, buttery delight priced at around $40, a true testament to quality ingredients and classic New England flavors.

Seafood lovers will appreciate the tuna burger—though uniquely prepared as ground tuna, it’s worth noting the departure from tradition—and the fried fish basket, praised for its crisp, golden coating and balanced seasoning. Sides like onion rings can be hit or miss, but the fries and lightly dressed salads provide a satisfying complement. Desserts, such as the butterscotch pudding, finish the meal on a sweet note.

The casual yet attentive service, open-air deck with harbor views, and straightforward pricing without hidden fees round out the appeal, making Straight Wharf Fish a standout on Nantucket’s culinary map.